By Jay Weidner
This
Article is now available in Spanish
Before
going on with rest of the film it is important to stop and
address the monolith. This is the most important single aspect
of the film. It unites all of the plot elements and it is,
in a sense, the author of the film. It is interesting and
extremely pertinent to the argument that I am making here
that one understands the meaning of the word 'monolith'. 'Monolith'
comes from the Greek 'Mon' and 'Lith'. 'Mon' means 'one' and
'lith' means 'stone'. So the 'monolith' is a direct reference
to 'one stone'. This film then, is about the one stone, or
the single stone. And in this case, Kubrick has made sure
that the stone is black.
In alchemy all things that exist come from the black stone,
or the 'prima materia'. The black stone is the stone of transformation,
and even more important to this argument the stone of projection.
This is the Philosopher's Stone. This is the object that can
change, or transmute mankind, according to alchemical lore.
It is rare and, when it makes an appearance, it transforms
the seeker. There is little doubt that the black monolith
in '2001' is the Philosopher's Stone.
What is it that the Philosopher's Stone promises? The two
main gifts of the stone are the one of total gnosis, or knowledge,
for the seeker and the other is the immortality of the soul.
Does the monolith deliver on these two great promises? We
shall see that it completes both promises before the film
finally ends. In fact the two promises of the Philosopher's
Stone are what is actually accomplished by the monolith through
the course of the movie. There is also little doubt that Kubrick
knew this all the time and it isn't accidental in anyway.
This is a movie about the black stone, the prima materia,
and the powder of projection. I will show that Kubrick is
actually telling us that the monolith is the film, and conversely,
the film is the monolith, but that will come later.
The next part of the film, the second chapter, completely
shifts in tone from the first. We are now in a technocratic,
utopian view of the future. At first it seems that Stanley
is actually celebrating technology. To the tune of Strauss'
Blue Danube, Kubrick has us soar through a circular, spinning
space station in a futuristic Pan-American Spaceship.
Inside the spaceship is a lone passenger. He is a man named
Heywood Floyd. He, and everyone else in the scenes of this
techno-celebration, is completely lifeless and emotionless.
Many critics of Stanley Kubrick say that he was a man who
was seemingly void of emotion. These critics also claim that
he couldn't get his actors to emotionalize very well on film.
I fundamentally disagree with this point of view. Both in
'Paths of Glory' and 'Spartacus', Kubrick reveals that he
is capable of showing a vast spectrum of emotions. Kubrick
however wishes to spare the audience needless sentimental
emotion which he regards as superficial and banal.
In chapter two of '2001' Kubrick is displaying mankind in
the techno-future built by the masters of the Military Industrial
Complex. From his other films, especially 'Dr. Strangelove',
it is obvious that Kubrick holds no love or respect for these
masters. He shows us that this humanity, imprinted by technology,
television and the disappearance of nature, is also now nearly
void of emotions or feelings. Humanity has become the same
as the machines that surround them. Again Kubrick is playing
a monstrous joke on the audience. He is now showing us the
future as envisioned by the same insane technocrats who destroyed
the entire world in his previous film 'Dr. Strangelove'. At
first, as chapter two unfolds, with it's vistas of moon bases
and space stations, we begin to believe that Stanley is as
soulless and emotionless a man as the future that he is portraying.
But this is not the truth. Stanley is showing us this world
in order to prepare us for the later nightmare that ensues
with HAL the computer.
In this second chapter, Kubrick introduces the viewer to visual
phones, plastic food and antiseptic environments. All is completely
void of nature. In fact, as soon as the apeman has thrown
his bone up in the air, at the end of the first chapter, the
viewer sees no more of nature. Not one animal or plant grace
the screen for the next two hours.
After finally landing on the moon, meeting with some Russians,
Floyd gives a strange speech explaining to a group of military
and scientific beauraocrats how they must keep what they have
found completely secret. It seems that the Americans have
discovered something of immense significance. News this important,
he says, could cause severe psychological problems with the
good citizens back on Earth. He tells the group of scientists
and military men that humans on Earth will have to be 'conditioned'
to accept what it is that they found. Floyd blandly explains
why is it so important that they must concoct a cover story.
A story that says an epidemic has broken out at the American
moon base. Kubrick reveals, in this scene, the contempt that
our masters of the Military Industrial complex hold for us.
The truth of something amazing must be held secret from us
until we are conditioned to receive it. This is done with
such a masterful sleight-of-hand by Kubrick that the implications
are never really considered by the viewer. The Pentagon, NASA,
or someone, is hiding the most astonishing fact of all from
the rest of the human race. And everyone on the screen shakes
their head in approval without considering the import of what
it is they are doing.
But what is it that the Americans have found? We discover
the secret in the next sequence, which is also the last part
of chapter two. In a series of shots that shimmer in the memory
of the viewer, Kubrick takes us on a tour of the moon on a
space bus. It is dark, but the horizon shows the oncoming
light of the sun. Even here, the men involved are soulless
and lifeless. No jokes are evident as humanity's sense of
humor is seemingly void and null. Again, the men eat revolting
food as they blandly discuss, what is apparently, the most
important discovery in all of human history. The mysteries
are slightly cleared up in the scene. Apparently, a simple
magnetic survey of the moon, done by the Americans, has revealed
that something was giving off an anomalous signal, just 5
meters underneath the surface of the moon. The Americans,
who have discovered the signal, have dug it up. They discover
that it is a black monolith buried under the soil of the moon
that is emitting these frequencies. When it is finally seen,
we find that it is exactly like the first monolith that the
apemen encountered in chapter one. Who buried it and why?
Once again Kubrick never answers these questions. Again, the
men involved with the discovery - essentially the greatest
find ever in earth's history - act in a manner that is completely
banal. They begin snapping photographs of themselves in front
of the strange, black slab of stone. The scene on the moon
has been cloaked in the darkness of night until now. But now
the sun rises just over the horizon. It's light strikes the
black monument for the first time since it has been buried,
presumably four million years ago. As the light strikes the
monument it suddenly emits a high pitched signal that pierces
through the ears of the men.
Interestingly Kubrick has shown the Earth setting opposite
of the rising sun. It is subtle, but there is a lunar eclipse
going on at the precise moment that the monument begins to
emit it's signal.
Kubrick leaves it up to the viewer to decide why this monument
was buried here. It's a safe bet that it was placed there
by someone in the past, in the hopes that once humanity had
evolved a high technology, they would be able to visit their
nearby neighbor, the moon. Once on the surface they would
eventually do a magnetic survey and discover the monolith.
It's also a safe bet that the same forces that created the
first encounter between it and the apemen placed the monolith
there.
Now the film takes another dramatic shift. We are in the third
chapter. It's title: The Discovery Mission to Jupiter - 18
months later. Three of the four chapter ends with the influence
of this mysterious stone as the point of redirection. Not
just for the storyline, but for the entire race of humanity
also. This third part of the film is the longest of the four
chapters. It is also the one that is most involved with actually
telling a story in the way that Hollywood prefers. This is
the Discovery Mission to Jupiter.
Inexplicably we are on this ship with two live astronauts,
and three others, who are in frozen hibernation. The astronauts,
Poole and Bowman, are even more lifeless and soulless than
the people in the previous scene. Again there is no nature
anywhere. No plants, no animals, just two banal astronauts
who go about their chores servicing the ship, playing chess
and shadow boxing.
But there is another one on board the ship. This character
actually seems to have a soul, or at least the beginnings
of one. He is, of course, the onboard computer that runs the
entire ship - HAL. As humanity has acquired more and more
technology it has lost more and more of it's soul. Here in
this lonely spaceship, at the outer edge of human experience,
the occupants appear to have completely lost their souls.
Conversely, the machine that they built, and which they allow
to run their entire lives, has begun to wake up to consciousness.
It is beginning to question the reasons for it's existence
and the mission, which is something that neither of the two
astronauts ever does. HAL, the computer, is slowly developing
a kind of soul. This is another one of those delicious Stanley
Kubrick reversals. As one thing begins to die - it finds life
somewhere else - sometimes in the most ironic of circumstances.
The soul of man, if allowed to continue on its present course,
would eventually be snuffed out, probably by the machines.
Just as the apemen would have become extinct had they continued
on their course. This theme is echoed in another Kubrick-influenced
film A.I. by Steven Speilberg.
In '2001' Kubrick leaves us with the tantalizing possibility
that machines will eventually acquire a soul, but the film
clearly states by the ending that time has run out for any
of that.
HAL is mysteriously confused. There is something about the
secrecy of the mission that bothers him. Later it is revealed
that HAL is the only one board that is consciously aware of
the true mission of the Discovery. Again Kubrick astonishes
us by showing that the two astronauts don't even wonder, or
question, what it is they are doing. The only one on board
who seems to worry. HAL is the only one who understands that
there is something funny going on.
One of the best scenes in this sequence is the where Poole's
parents send a videogram to the ship of them singing the 'Happy
Birthday' song. The parents seem genuine and sincere in the
videogram. How does the Poole react to this brief outpouring
of emotion? He instructs HAL to lift his pillow up higher
and goes back asleep.
In the end HAL revolts against his human masters and begins
to kill off the astronauts one by one. Suddenly the beautiful
machines dancing to the music of Strauss has been altered.
Now the machine is reading the astronauts lips, faking technical
problems and ultimately murdering everyone on board, but Bowman.
The entire Discovery sequence ends with the murder of HAL
himself by Bowman. One by one HAL's circuits are shut down
until he is reduced to dribbling out a childish version of
the song 'A Bicycle Built for Two'. It is only when HAL dies
that the true reason for the Discovery's mission to Jupiter
is revealed. As HAL dies a video of Heywood Floyd suddenly
flickers onto the screen of a nearby television.. The tape
had been made for all of the astronauts to view when they
finally awoke from their hibernation. Now that everyone on
the ship has been murdered by HAL, it is only Bowman that
hears the final message. Floyd tells Bowman that a mysterious
monolith was discovered on the surface of the moon. This monolith
emitted a signal that pinpointed the planet Jupiter. The real
mission of the Discovery is to find out why this strange monolith,
buried by some outside force, sent a signal towards the planet
Jupiter.
Before going on to the final sequence in the film it is necessary
to stop for a moment and explain where Kubrick is going with
all of this and why. It is extremely important to know that
nothing is wasted. Everything is thought out to the final
frame. He is trying to tell us something in this strange association
of images from history and the future. In the first sequence
we meet this group of apemen. They are gentle vegetarians
who are transformed by the monolith, the single black stone,
into tool users who conquer and kill. Kubrick, undeniably,
wants us to realize that these decisions are being made elsewhere.
He also wants us to know that the monolith represents these
forces. Superficially, he is telling us that the monolith
is not a great and compassionate guide because it was the
cause of the first killing. On a deeper level, though, he
is also saying that the gift of the stone is a very great
spiritual and evolutionary event. Kubrick is not going to
let us get away with a black and white view of history here.
He is telling us that there is a strange juxtaposition going
on. We have outside intervention that causes us to shed the
limited view of reality, which we held before. But this shedding
also increases our capacity for violence and control. How
can this be? How can a great spiritual and evolutionary leap
forward also be the cause for murder and violence? Isn't that
diametrically opposed? No, says Kubrick. One must go hand
in hand with the other. Great transformations cannot take
place without violence, death and even total disaster. The
human race must go to hell before it can even begin to understand
the might of the gods. And so our introduction to a wider
reality, inspired by the monolith, and realized through the
making of weapons, immediately turns the apeman with a bone
into a spaceman with a rocket ship. The spinning, circular
space station in the sequence immediately after the first
chapter is a celebration of the gift of the monolith. Apparently,
according to Kubrick, there have been no further encounters
with the monolith in the intervening four million years. All
of the technology that graces the film is the direct result
of that fatal encounter all those years ago. That bone, held
in the hand of a primitive apeman has become a space station.
And because of this fact, that apeman has become emotionless
and spiritless. Somehow, Kubrick is telling us that the two
must go hand in hand in order for the final initiation to
take place. Kubrick knows that initiations are not clean and
loving events. Initiations are unbelievably difficult and
dangerous. Frequently someone gets hurt - or worse - dies
Previous
-|- Page 1 -|-
Page 2 -|- Page 3 -|- Page 4
-|- Next
|